A Game Everybody Likes?

Balladeer wrote:

No complaints here.  And you need to change your signature.  

There's always going to be results from here on out. (cheers, always forget to change it  )

I'd agree with Xenoblade. Also, Phoenix Wright is popular around here, isn't it? From what I've played of Ghost Trick, that looks like its going on my list...

YES BOTH OF THOSE.

Not played xenoblade, ghost trick. Didn't like phoenix wright, the 1st Luigi Mansion is fine with me.

What about Eternal Darkness or Beyond Good & Evil, everyone likes them right.

GAMES WE ALL LIKE!

1. Super Mario Galaxy
2. WarioWare, Inc.: Mega Microgame$!
3. Super Smash Bros. Melee

I don't like 1 or 2 and shanks doesn't like 3.

How's about Tetris on the Game Boy?

YES Zero, everyone lies Tetris even your Nan likes it.

High score games are rubbish. Granted, I've not played the GB original, but I've played the DS game and they're all the same.

What about eternal darkness or beyond good and evil then balla.

Never played 'em. Probably would like BG&E, probably wouldn't like ED, but the latter is like Phillips ignoring any JRPG off the bat.

Now this is getting hard, to think of something everyone likes.

As phillps not a fan of jrpgs, balla not a fan of shooters or anything manly or high score driven, andy doesn't like games from the N64 apart from Paper Mario.

Woah woah woah... you don't like Super Mario Galaxy?!  

Also, Phillips did say that if someone's not played a game then their opinion doesn't really count in regards to that game:

Phillips wrote:

For the purposes of this thread, I'm not wanting to hear the opinions of people who have only played a demo of the game discussed, or played it for ten minutes, or saw a video of it on YouTube, or just didn't fancy the looks of it. I could say that any given Japanese RPG is automatically shite on the grounds that it's a Japanese RPG, but have I played most of them? No. So what's my opinion worth here? Nowt, that's what. Let's give these games a fair crack of the whip, me included.

So we can put forward any game really.

Here's one for you - Portal.

No I don't like either galaxies because of the controls.

I love Portal.

Fair enough - if there was complaint I could throw at Galaxy, it's that the controls can be a little shite at times. I still love it though.

One for Portal!  

Right, from me...

Luigi's Mansion 1 - Yeah
Luigi's Mansion 2 - Yeah
Xenoblade - Don't have an opinion
Tetris - Yeah
Ace Attorney 1 - Yeah
Ace Attorney 2 - No
Ace Attorney 3 (and after) - Don't know
Eternal Darkness - No
BG&E - No
Portal - Don't know

masofdas wrote:

What about eternal darkness or beyond good and evil then

I never chimed in here. Never played Eternal Darkness so can't chip in, and I'd have said yes to BG&E, but Phillips isn't a fan anyway.

Are we back down to no games we all like then?  

Luigi Mansion 1 seems to be only game at the moment people like.

Portal and Tetris: yes, please!

I can't believe anyone who disliked Galaxy is the same species as me.

Portal and Tetris are yes's here too, just don't go bringing up the awful pile of ass that is Portal 2.

I said I disliked galaxies because of the control scheme, The actual game might be fantastic I just don't like how you play it. This is why I'm disappoint with 3D World's being the 3D Mario were getting, I wanted a proper 3D Mario as I've not played one properly since sunshine.

Tetris is out Balla doesn't like it.

Luigi Mansion still seems to be the only game we can agree on, what about Wind Waker, Twilight Princess, Skyward Sword, Metal Gear Solid, Soul Calibur, Crash Bandicoot 3.

Pretty sure Phillips will shoot down the Zelda's but I'm fine with those 3. Metal Gear gets a resounding no from me though.

Soul Calibur 2, yeah - not the first one.

SoulCalibur II is fine with me as long as it's not the PS2 version. Why NO to MGS it's a classic, twin snakes sits nicely on my shelf.

masofdas wrote:

Luigi Mansion still seems to be the only game we can agree on, what about Wind Waker, Twilight Princess, Skyward Sword, Metal Gear Solid, Soul Calibur, Crash Bandicoot 3.

Wind Waker - Don't know
Twilight Princess - Don't know
Swyward Sword - No
MGS - Yes
Soul Calibur - Yes
Crash 3 - Yes

Metal Gear is a slog, the stealth isn't very good, the shooting is worse and the original is so dated it's barely playable. Playing it means fighting an urge to go and play something else, it's just not very good. I didn't think much more of 3 other than that it had a reasonably good story and better shooting.

MGS 4 is the reason I bought a PS3, the series is that good.

So SoulCalibur 2 & Luigi Mansion 1 are the game's we can all agree on at the moment.